HARC       

Historic Architectural Review Commission
8 October 2002

 

The Historic Architectural Review Commission of the City of Key West, Florida, will hold a regular meeting on Tuesday, October 8, 2002 at 3 p.m., second floor, Old City Hall, 510 Greene Street, Key West, Florida.

Notice to Applicants: Once HARC approval is obtained a building permit application must be submitted. The Building Department will call the applicant when a building permit is ready to be issued.

*If your project is reviewed at this meeting, and deferred for additional information or for re-design, you must submit the required documentation within one week of this meeting to be included on the next agenda. There will be no exceptions as this material must be available for public review at least five days before a meeting.   

Please Note: Chapter 286- Public Business: Miscellaneous Provisions

   286.0105   Notices of meetings and hearings must advise that a record is required to appeal. –Each board, commission, or agency of this state or of any political subdivision thereof shall include in the notice of any meeting or hearing, if notice of the meeting or hearing is required, of such board, commission, or agency, conspicuously on such notice, the advice that, if a person decides to appeal any decision made by the board, agency, or commission with respect to any matter considered at such meeting or hearing, he or she will need a record of the proceedings, and that, for such purpose, he or she may need to ensure that a verbatim record of the proceedings is made, which record includes the testimony and evidence upon which the appeal is to be based. The requirements of this section do not apply to the notice provided in s. 200.065(3).

 

City of Key West Planning Department, Notice to HARC Applicants

If you are in the process of improving your property or making structural changes, there may be more required of you than the design and beautification requirements from HARC.

1.      Please be advised that if you are contemplating an addition to your building (whether an additional story, or on the same level), you may need to go through the variance process.

2.      If an additional structure is planned, whether separate or linked in any manner to the main or existing building, some configurations may trigger the variance application process.

3.      Many alterations will need to meet the basic setbacks, building coverage and other requirements that are zone-specific.

Sometimes, simple changes in building plans now may help you avoid going through another process at a later date, delaying your project.

If you or your contractor, architect or other professional representative need further information, please visit us at 605-A Simonton, or call for an appointment at (305) 292-8189. 

 

Call to order.
Roll call.
Invocation.
Approval of last minutes

Meeting Procedure:
Applications for consent agenda.
Applications requiring clarification.
Deferrals (projects deferred from previous meeting).
Other business.
Adjournment.

 

STAFF APPROVALS:

 

H02-09-13-1284 1300 Virginia Street, Gary the Carpenter

 Replace rear door with single lite French door. Replace front jalousie door with     4 panel. Paint exterior white.

                                   

           APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-13-1283 404 Grinnell Street, Guillermo Orozco

 (Addendum to H02-07-12-978) Project was approved by HARC rear porch

  was relocated to provide better access from kitchen/dinning area.

                                   

           APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED

 

H02-09-13-1290 631 Greene Street, Southernmost Signs

 Wall 96’ X 48” wood sign “Mote Marine Laboratory Key West” (Summerland

 Key, * Sarasota Charlotte Harbor).

 

           APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-13-1293 410 Catherine Street, Sean Copping

 Demolition of 11’ X 21’ CBS rear addition and 20’ X 30’ wood canopy rear

              addition.

                                   

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-13-1297 505/507 Whitehead Street, Thomas E. Pope, P.A.

 Revision to earlier submittal per Committees comments. See H02-06-28-901.

                                   

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-13-1298 206 Fleming Street, Thomas E. Pope, P.A.

 Extend roof to cover existing rear porch.

            

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-13-1299 1006 Southard Street, Steven Uiterwyk

 Replace eleven (11) linear feet of picket fence, less than 4 feet high.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-16-1301 1215 Varela Street, Leroy Enterprises

 Replaster pool and change waterline tile.

 

APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-16-1302 606 Dey Street, Agnes H. Depoo

Replace rotten siding & rotten balcony 20’ X 24’-siding.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-16-1303 818 White Street, A Plus Roofing

Install 2500 sq/ft of Cooley c-3 White thermo plastic Ply roof system on

existing flat roof.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-16-1304 512Caroline Street, Thornburgh Construction Co

 Replace 200 sq/ft of wood siding one window (to be custom made 100 lf

 Decking 2 X 6’s. Paint siding-White.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-17-1305 1021 Angela Street, Victor’s Roofing

 Re-roof front porch shed roof 1.5 sq Bitimin rubber 90165.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-17-1306 624 Frances Street, A Plus Roofing

Maintenance and Silver paint v-crimp metal roof.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-17-1307 618 Duval Street, David Lee Roofing

 Re-roof remove existing. Install base sheet tapered insulation modified

 base sheet can’t strip modified roofing in hot asphalt waterproof back

             wall. Estimated $60.000.00 work.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-17-1308 800 Fleming Street, Lee Mattingly

    Exterior change 2 doors to swing out. Install new weather

    Stripping & threshold touch- up paint to match (White)

   

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-17-1309 800 Olivia Street, David Trujillo

 Replace rotten fascia board 12’.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED_____

 

H02-09-17-1310 1109 Stump Lane, Tony Rettanwander

 Remove existing 6’ picket fence in front. Install new 4’ picket fence according

 to HARC Guidelines. (30ft.).

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-13-1311 618 Whitehead Street, A. Paula Cottis

Repair rotting sills & rotting siding where necessary; Paint building same color

 as is. Recess exterior plumbing pipes water & stacks; Resurface front cement

porch & steps. (1,500-sq/ft siding)

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-18-1313 1119 Catherine Street, Total Temp

 Install 2 Central A/C’s.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-18-1314 100/102 Olivia Street, Total Temp

 Install 2 new Central A/C’s.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-18-1315 1420 Simonton Street, Mark Rossi

 Replace nasty windows with glass doors (4 sets) and re-side with

  ships (siding 1000 lf).

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-18-1316 406 United Street, Mattingly Construction

 Remove approximately 35 sq/ft of sidewalk & 8 l/ft of curb.

 Form for modified curb & sidewalk to allow for driveway access.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-18-1317 408 United Street, William Robbins

 Combo ironwork and hedge fence along front of property for (49’) 4’       tall.

            

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-18-1318 406 United Street, William Robbins

 Combo ironwork and hedge fence along front of property (49) X 4’tall.

            

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-18-1319 1022 James Street, Dan Ace Roofing

 Remove v-crimp roofing & install galvanized v-crimp roofing.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-18-1320 120 Angela Street, C.B.S. Services 

 Installation of 4 A/C systems.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

 H02-09-18-1321 708 Southard Street, A Plus Roofing

  Install 100 sq/ft of flintastic ‘SBS’ rubberized single ply on refurbished

  shed roof.

  

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-18-1322 1006 Fleming Street, Key West A/C

 Install Central A/C.                       

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED

 

H02-09-19-1323 101 Simonton Street, Keystar, Inc.

 Replace double hung windows with new same type double hung windows

                           (19) Wood. (Approved (by V.M.).

Move existing wooden sash window 4’ to right on west side of Bldg.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED

 

H02-09-19-1324 0 Duval Street, William Marine Construction

Repair spa1led concrete on existing seawall cap and install 174

X lf of concrete sidewalk.

                        

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-19-1325 416 Greene Street, Dan Ace Roofing

Install hot mopped rubber (Flat roof).

.

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-19-1326 1004 Packer Street, A Plus Roofing

 Install 1300 sq/ft of 26g Galvanized v-crimp metal on new built

 structure.

                            

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-19-1327 1402 Pine Street, A Plus Roofing

              Install 150 sq/ft of Cooley c-3 White thermo plastic single ply on rear flat

 Porch roof. Maintenance and paint (Silver paint) existing metal single roof

 System.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-19-1328 Josephine Parker Lane, Hurricane Shutters of K.W.

 Aluminum panels on 5 doors, aluminum Bahama shutters on 4 windows, to

 Make existing aluminum Bahamas.

             .

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-19-1331 914 Eaton Street, Chodzin, Inc.

 The lounge roof repair 416 sf of galvanized metal Vic-singled roof as

  necessary.

       

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-19-1332 130 Duval Street, Chodzin, Inc.

 Repair: Install 100 sf of SBS single roofing systems.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-20-1333 914 Eaton Street, Chodzin, Inc.

Room# 13 Install 231 sf of SBS single Ply roofing.

 

          APPROVED     X        DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED

 

H02-09-20-1334 322 Margaret Street, Chodzin, Inc.

Install skylight & flashing.

 

APPROVED     X        DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-20-1335 1075 Duval Street, Sub Zero A/C

Change out of a 2-ton A/C.

 

APPROVED     X        DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-23-1337 1020 Duval Street, Sub Zero A/C

           Install a 5-ton A/C with 9 drop.

                                    

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-24-1338 200 Greene Street, Bill Sprague

           Handicap lift to be installed at front stairway with Elec. Storm drainage

    as per drawings 18 Sept.02.on roof.

                                    

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-24-1339 604 Greene Street, HTM, LLC

 Lobby-1/12 ton A/C Suite-206-11/2 ton, Suite-204-11/2 ton, Suite-202 11/2

           Ton, Suite-200 11/2 ton=5 1 ½ ton A/C units.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-24-1340 319 Duval Street, Key West A/C

 Install Central A/C.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-24-1342 308 Margaret Street, Boston Brick

 Installation of brick pavers walkway, patios, and pool deck, manufactured

 brick, approx.1,040 sq/ft.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-24-1343 210 Elizabeth Street, Harris/Kjos Construction

 Paint exterior colors as per sample trim/siding.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-25-1344 1007 United Street, Holtkamp Construction

 Remove existing deck boards and replace with new 2 X6 PT approx.

 600 sq/ft.                            

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-25-1345 1122 Angela Street, A Plus Roofing

 Install 500 sq/ft of 26 g Galvanized V-crimp metal roofing on new

 Built side porch addition.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

H02-09-25-1346 906 White Street, Toolbox GC

New windows, doors, gable roof at existing cottage. New ½ bath-17 sq/ft.

Paint BM Say brook Sage HC-114 to match Main House.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-25-1347 306 Peacon Lane, Paul McGrail

 Move existing fence back six ft. on left side. Brick in area for scooter

 Parking. *Previously I pulled permit to remove entire fence #02-0000

 0958. The fence is still in place as I decide against removing it entirely.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-25-1349 206-1 Southard Street, Oceanair Co.

 Replace 1.5-ton condenser and Air Handler.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-25-1350 709 Eaton Street, Chodzin, Inc.

 Repair galvanized metal Vic shingles. Install SBS single Ply roof

 systems on flat roofs.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-25-1351 703 Catherine Street, Richard Heuele

 Remove side-by-side sash windows and replace with its lite wooden

 Recycle French doors as per attached. Remove wooden windows (single 2

 double and replace with the same as per attached. Paint metal shingle roof.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-25-1352 1316 Duval Street, Hurricane Shutters of K.W.

 15 Windows w/decorative colonial structures Dark Green (Essex Green).

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-25-1354 1007 Simonton Street, Southernmost Signs

 1 Wall sign 12’ H Café wood letters 7’ logo (“CAFÉ DES ARTISTES

  A SEAFOOD PLACE”).

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-26-1355 1004 Duval Street, D.L. Porter Construction Inc.

 Replace, Repair, Design, Landscape around Pool area.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-26-1357 1116 Whitehead Street, Walter Price

 Replace rotten siding along ground on each side of house and along the

 roof edge.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-26-1358 502 Whitehead Street, Monroe County Public Works

 Remove approx. 45’ lf of non-load bearing wall (interior). Install 6 lf of

 2 X 4 partition wall to match existing.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-26-1359 703 South Street, Steve Ness/Canvas Creations

 Fabricate and install new canvas awning over porch deck of home on 1st

 floor. Note: Will not be sent from front of home.

 

          APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-27-1360 915 Duval Street, Southernmost Signs

 1 Wall sign 3’ w X 1’h wood sign “NINE ONE FIVE RESTAURANT”.

 

           APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-27-1361 530 Southard Street, Crown Castle South Inc.

 Repair/ Maintenance of existing Tower.

 

            APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-27-1362 1111 Eaton Street, Thomas Kelly

 Relocate existing overhead door to southeast elevation. Replace existing s/h

              windows w/Hortz sliders.

 

            APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-27-1364 525 Duval Street, A plus Roofing

 Tear old 90 lb roofing and dispose to dump. Install 1800 sq/ft of Cooley C-3

              White thermo plastic single Ply roofing.

 

            APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-27-1366 402 Duval Street, Sun Masters

 Install reusable storm panels on storefront.

 

            APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

H02-09-30-1369 716 Thomas Street, Grace Jemison

 Replace 3 sqs. of metal sheet roofing (rear) flat roof.

 

            APPROVED     X          DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

 

APPLICATIONS REQUIRING CLARIFICATION:

 

CL1.  H02-09-10-1261 1010 Fleming Street, Creative Construction

          Replace 4’ Casement windows w/ wooden D.H. 6/6 sash

           windows. Replace 2 existing shutters w/flat skylights.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

 

 

CL2.  H02-09-20-1330 812 Baptist Lane, Jason Barroso

          Provide & install board and batten as per submittals.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

CL3.  H02-09-16-1300 213/217 Telegraph Lane, Peter Pike

                      Replace existing steps at 3 locations, construct raised stage.

           Install 6’ privacy boards. Install screening for walk-in Freezer.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

CL4.  H02-09-24-1341 513 William Street, Ruth Scadlock

          Construct wood access ramp @ front of house (after the fact).

          

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

CL5.  H02-09-25-1353 413 B Emma Street, Deal Builders, Inc.

          Construct 2 Balconies on the rear of the structure.

          

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

CL6. H02-09-27-1363 828 Windsor Lane, John P. Baker

                      Remove fence where picket 4’ high, front only w/hip roof. Install batten

          strips & casing.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

CL7.  H02-09-27-1365 716 Emma Street, Andy Schottenstien

           Addition of 2 skylights or if possible, 2 dormers and roof.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

CL8.  H02-09-27-1367 525 Louisa Street, Thomas E. Pope, P.A.

Renovation of existing 1 Story frame residence. New 11/2 Story addition at rear. Replace 2 existing windows with double full lite doors wood        deck, pool, and terrace.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

CL9.  H02-09-27-1368 410 Catherine Street, Sean Copping

New rear addition side entry porch, pool, deck, and pergola. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

DEFERRALS:

 

D1. H02-08-27-1190 604 Frances Street, Joseph Semiller

      After the fact: Change to windows (6 over 6 wood frame window), put

       On new window. Add 25 sq/ft of siding. Add new rail.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

APROVED              DISAPPROVED              DEFERRED______

D2. H02-08-30-1227 608 Duval Street, Ralph Sanchez

      Replace existing storefront.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

APPROVED              DISAPPROVED              DEFERRED______

 

D3.  H02-08-16-1142 700 White Street, James Elwood/Jenny Stones

                     Remove existing addition. Construct 15’ X 28’8” addition and patio roof. Relocate existing windows to new addition, 3 windows in the original structure. Replace approximately 50 cedar shingles and 100 square feet of siding. Repair/replace concrete piers. Paint house white. New pool. 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED______

 

D4.   H02-09-12-1278 620 Eaton Street & 416 Elizabeth Street, Michel Thoulouze

                      Restore & renovate existing structures & move late addition to Adjacent property. New covered porch & pool.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

                   APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED

 

D5.   H02-09-13-1292 822 Terry Lane, C. Leon Williams

                      278 sq. ft. 2nd story rear addition over existing living room, dining. kitchen.  Roofline matches existing addition with loft, adding about 4’2” to the height at rear.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

        APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED

 

D6.   H02-08-1225 516 White Street, Thomas E. Pope, P.A.

   Second story addition to existing historic garage/ warehouse building.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED

 

D7.   H02-08-02-1090 101 Petronia Street, Erik Neuenfeldt

                      New 2 ½ Story Timber Frame Residence.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

     APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED

 

D8. H02-07-12-965 623 Thomas Street, Griffin Moore

    Rehabilitation of rear wall and addition of rear porch and storage.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

      APPROVED             DISAPPROVED             DEFERRED

 

Other Business:

The Historic Architectural Review Commission of the City of Key West, Florida, will hold a regular meeting on Tuesday, October 8, 2002 at 3 p.m., second floor, Old City Hall, 510 Greene Street, Key West, Florida.

APPLICATIONS REQUIRING CLARIFICATION:

CL1 1010 Fleming Street, Replace 4’ Casement windows w/ wooden D.H. 6/6 sash

windows. Replace 2 existing shutters w/flat skylights.

CL2. 812 Baptist Lane, Install board and batten siding.

CL3. 213/217 Telegraph Lane, Replace existing steps at 3 locations, construct raised stage.

           Install 6’ privacy boards. Install screening for walk-in Freezer.

CL4. 513 William Street,  Construct wood access ramp @ front of house (after the fact).

CL5. 413 B Emma Street, Construct 2 balconies on the rear of the structure.

CL6. 828 Windsor Lane, Remove fence, new porch with hip roof. Install  batten strips & casing.

CL7. 716 Emma Street, Addition of 2 skylights or if possible, 2 dormers and roof.

CL8. 525 Louisa Street, Renovation of existing residence. New 11/2 Story addition at rear. Replace 2 existing windows with double full lite doors wood deck, pool, and terrace.

CL9. 410 Catherine Street, New rear addition side entry porch, pool, deck, and pergola. 

 

DEFERRALS:

D1. 604 Frances Street, After the fact: Change door to window.  On new window. Add 25 sq/ft of siding. Add new rail.

D2. 608 Duval Street, Replace existing Storefront.

D3. 700 White Street, Remove existing addition. Construct 15’ X 28’8” addition and patio roof. Relocate existing windows to new addition, 3 windows in the original structure. Replace approximately 50 cedar shingles and 100 square feet of siding. Repair/replace concrete    piers. Paint house white. New pool. 

D4.  620 Eaton Street & 416 Elizabeth Street,  Restore & renovate existing structures & move late addition to adjacent property. New covered porch & pool.

D5. 822 Terry Lane,  278 sq. ft. 2nd story rear addition over existing living room, dining, kitchen.

D6. 516 White Street, Second story addition to existing historic garage/ warehouse building.

D7. 101 Petronia Street, New 2 ½ Story Timber Frame Residence.

D8.  623 Thomas Street, Rehabilitation of rear wall and addition of rear porch and storage.